Here’s When To Replace A Pickleball Paddle: What is a Dead Paddle?


A “dead” pickleball paddle is a paddle that has lost the quality of performance. This can be caused by a break and overuse of the paddle. 
Here’s When To Replace A Pickleball Paddle: What is a Dead Paddle?

Just because you finally went in on a $150+ paddle, does not mean it’s going to last you a lifetime. 

If you’re playing pickleball frequently and maybe have an angry or excited outburst here or there, you’re slowly wearing down the integrity of your paddle. 

But how do you know when to replace your paddle? Here’s a full guide on the signs of a worn-down paddle, the steps to take to prolong the lifespan, and thoughts to consider when the time comes to say goodbye and get a replacement.

What is a Dead Pickleball Paddle?

A “dead” pickleball paddle is a paddle that has lost the quality of performance. This can be caused by a break, crack, dent, worn down surface, or overuse for the lifespan of the paddle. 

You know your paddle is “dead” when you’ve played a couple of games, and you just can’t find the sweet spot, and maybe the sound is a little off. This is the first sign that you have a dead paddle. Here are some other signs of a worn-down pickleball paddle.

Conversely, if you have a paddle that seems excessively powerful and sounds louder and clunkier than normal, you could have a delaminated paddle on your hands.  

What is Delamination on Pickleball Paddles?

When a paddle delaminates it means that the face has disconnected from the core. The adhesive that is connecting the paddle to the core has unadhered which can work as a spring giving players MORE power.

Delamination mainly occurs on thermoformed, unibody carbon fiber paddles. Because they are unibody and have one layer, as opposed to other paddles that have multiple layers, delamination is a much more prevalent issue. 

If you suddenly notice that your paddle has a surge of power and a loud unnatural sound, then your paddle is delaminated and needs replacing.

Signs Your Pickeball Paddle is Worn Out

Paddles can get worn out in many ways here are the issues I tend to see or have personally experienced. 

  • The edge guard can come loose or fall off. 
  • The surface can lose grittiness and become less easy to control and spin with. 
  • The core can break down and start to rattle. 
  • The handle can break off from the base of the paddle (probably the easiest one of these to diagnose). 
  • If you play with it long enough, it can develop dead spots that affect the sound, feel, sweet spot and consistency of your paddle.

Resource: Graphite Vs. Composite Pickleball Paddles

How Often Should You Buy a New Pickleball Paddle?

Well, what type of player are you? Not all players are created equal, and not everyone will have the same standards for how long a paddle is playable. Determining your level and play type/goals is key in answering the question of when to replace your paddle.

Ben Johns, the number one male player of all time, has said that he changes pickleball paddles once every tournament or so. On the other end of the spectrum, I play with a buddy who has been playing with the same “starter” paddle for three years and counting.

How much you play, how aggressive you are, and what kind of paddle performance you demand are all critical variables determining when a paddle needs to be replaced. 

Generally, I would recommend changing your paddle once you realize any of the issues above are starting to arise.

Need Help Deciding Which Paddle to Get? Check out: Pickleball Paddle Buying Guide

Do Different Paddles Have Different Lifespans?

Absolutely. In general, any paddle that has a spray on the surface will lose it’s grit and texture much faster than a woven carbon fiber face. Carbon fiber is currently the top-of-the-line material in terms of performance and durability.

How About Warranties?

I’m glad you asked. As you have probably noticed, these pickleball paddles aren’t cheap. All of the reputable companies have manufacturer warranties that cover many of the issues listed in the first paragraph above.

Check with your particular company if you are having an issue and chances are, if you bought the paddle in the last 6 months or so, it is likely covered and they will send you out a replacement (as long as they determine damage is not due to normal wear and tear).

Paddle Care Tips

Pickleball paddles aren’t exactly monarch butterfly wings that need to be handled with gloves and tweezers at all times. But taking care of them will help ensure they last as long as they can before wearing out. So here are the top 5 tips for caring for your paddle:

1. Get a case.

They are inexpensive, sleek, and will guard your paddle from unnecessary damage while not in play.

2. Keep your paddle out of the sun/extreme temperatures.

The materials inside the paddle do not handle high heat or cold well. If you have a really nice paddle and leave it inside your car with the windows up on a summer day, do not be surprised if a crazed pickleballer smashes your window to liberate it.

3. Do not let it get wet (or dry it ASAP if it does).

Moisture can ruin a paddle face very quickly and thoroughly.

4. Don’t tap paddles, or if you do, take it easy.

It’s tempting to emphatically slam your paddle with your teammate after an awesome Erne or ATP, but resist the urge! Too much impact can lead to all kinds of problems for paddles.

5. Keep it clean.

Again, this isn’t rocket science. We all learned in kindergarten if we want our toys to last we need to take care of them. Use a lint-free or microfiber cloth (no household cleaners!) to wipe down the hitting surface on your pickleball paddle.


Your pickleball paddle will wear out whether you’re a frequent pickleball player, professional, or weekend warrior. 

If your paddle isn’t covered under warranty, don’t let that discourage you. With all the paddles on the market, it can be an exciting opportunity to try out a different paddle that better suits your game. 

When you do get that fresh new paddle you’ll know how to take better care of it to hopefully prolong it’s lifespan.

Written by:

Daniel Hawk

Daniel Hawk is a Northern California transplant from the Washington D.C. area. He grew up playing as much basketball as he possibly could while mixing in tennis, ping pong, and whatever other sports he could find that would get his heart rate going, test his reflexes, and fuel his competitive drive. He picked up pickleball in 2021 and has never looked back. Daniel is a 4.5 player who is constantly studying the game and working to improve. Daniel has been writing his whole life. His father is a professional editor who helped imprint the beauty and necessity of clear writing in Daniel at an early age. He studied English at the University of Colorado on Boulder and has written countless works of fiction and nonfiction since.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Scroll to Top